Showing posts with label U.S. Justice Department. Show all posts
Showing posts with label U.S. Justice Department. Show all posts

Saturday, April 4, 2026

Non-Stick Pam

Pam Bondi is out as Attorney General.
Donald Trump fired her for numerous reasons one of them being her complete lack of media savviness.  The hearing in which she was forced to talk about the Epstein files and defended Trump by citing the Dow hitting 50,000 points (thanks to the Iran war, it's since gone way down for that) and referring to House members by their last names without salutations, made her like the fool she is, and even Trump understood that.  She just didn't look good on TV.
Seeing as how Trump wanted a woman who was good  on television to serve as the nation's top law enforcement officer, I'm surprised he didn't appoint Pam Dawber.
But then that would make sense.  At least Pam Dawber could act like an Attorney General!
But there were a couple of other reasons Trump ousted Bondi.  No mater how corrupt she was at trying to shield Trump from the Epstein files and allowing him to break the law, she wasn't corrupt enough.  And even though she prosecuted many of Trump's enemies as part of his revenge against folks who tried to prosecute him - James Comey, Letitia James - the cases got thrown out of court.  She was not the sort of Attorney General who could successfully keep the Epstein files under wraps completely, and she did not have the necessary skills to make any cases against Trump's adversaries stick.  Now that she's gone, Trump hopes to find someone who can outdo her - and given how there are probably more federal judges out there who might make it easier for the Justice Department to prosecute Trump's enemies, like Aileen Cannon, than we might think, Trump might find the right Attorney General to do his dirty work.
For now, Trump has Assistant Attorney General Todd Blanche, one of his personal attorneys from the 2024 fraud trial, as acting Attorney General to ignore the law, and Environmental Protection Agency director Lee Zeldin, who has spent the past year and change ignoring the ecosystem, is the likeliest permanent successor to Bondi.  Whether either Blanche or Zeldin can cover up the Epstein files and fuck up Comey and James well enough to satisfy Trump remains to be seen.  (Zeldin graduated from Albany Law School, which, as far as I know, is like Ed's Law School on the late Tony Randall's eponymous late-seventies sitcom; when you have an Attorney General who holds a law degree from a school you'd never heard before he took office, expect amateur hour.)  As for Bondi, she can expect endless hours of testifying under oath once Democrats regain the House of Representatives and start investigating her and her old boss.   
And that Republican Party-friendly Italian-American group on Facebook that celebrated that Italian-American Bondi for becoming the first female attorney general appointed by a Republican President won't be talking so loudly about her in the future. 

Monday, January 13, 2025

Biden's Achilles Heel

His name is Merrick Garland.

When President Biden was selecting his Cabinet, the chief candidates were former acting Attorney General Sally Yates, who had stood against Trump at the beginning of his first presidential term, and Doug Jones, the half-term Alabama Democratic senator who lost his bid for a full six-year term to the insufferable Tommy Tuberville.  But Biden chose Garland in part because he had a reputation for being even-handed, fair-minded, and many other hyphenated adjectives, I'm sure, which made Garland the perfect man to restore integrity to the Justice Department.  Also, since Garland was a federal judge, making him U.S. Attorney General meant that Biden could replace him with a young woman of color on the bench.  (Garland's replacement on the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals, Ketanji Brown Jackson, would be elevated to the Supreme Court only a year after taking Garland's place; that seat is now occupied by another woman, Taiwanese-American Judge Florence Pan.) 

But Biden chose Garland for an additional reason; President Obama had nominated Garland to a vacancy on the Supreme Court, only to see Mitch McConnell deny Garland a hearing and hold the seat open until a Republican - Trump - was elected to fill the seat.  This was Biden's way of sticking it to Senate Republicans who had denied Judge Garland a seat on the Supreme Court five years earlier.  No one - not even President Biden - could have known how badly he had misjudged his man.  Having taken office so soon after the January 6 insurrection, Attorney General Garland began investigating the foot soldiers of the insurrection - the Proud Boys, the Oath Keepers, and other rabble-rousers on the verge of being pardoned.  Ominously absent from Garland's cross-hairs was the Chief Insurrectionist himself, Donald J. Trump. 

Garland explained his method as starting at the bottom and working his way up, but this obvious presumption of innocence toward Trump flew in the face of what Americans clearly saw and heard on their television screens on that day of congressional certification of the 2020 presidential election. Trump was clearly responsible for the insurrection, and the January 6 committee in the House clearly confirmed this in their hearings.  But because Garland didn't seek to have Trump investigated for January 6, he took his sweet time and waited until the hearings concluded.  Then all of those classified documents were found at Mar-a-Lago.  

Not until late 2022 did Garland finally move to appoint Jack Smith to investigate Trump for both the insurrection and the classified documents; by then, it was too late.  Trump and his lawyers took advantage of every opportunity, no matter how contrived, to delay the January 6 case (Judge Aileen Cannon helped delay the classified-documents case before dismissing it altogether on a technicality) to the point where it (like the classified-documents case) would never, ever go to trial.  All we get as a consolation prize is Smith's report on the insurrection case.

So Garland, by moving too slowly to prosecute Trump to avoid the appearance of being political and to restore the integrity of the Justice Department,  let politics take precedence over the rule of law and set up the Justice Department for a further erosion of integrity.  And President Biden was stuck with him.  He couldn't fire Garland because it would look . . . political. 

Especially when President Biden himself was investigated for having classified documents in his possession and when Hunter Biden was also investigated - both by Garland. 

Oh yeah, President Biden calls Garland his biggest regret.  As far as I'm concerned, he should have, if he wanted to name a black woman as his running mate, made Val Demings his vice presidential candidate and appointed Kamala Harris Attorney General.
As a result of Biden's personnel choices, Garland is going to go down in history as the worst Attorney General since John Mitchell - and Mitchell  went to prison for breaking the letter and the spirit of the law, whereas Garland ironically undistinguished himself by going by the book.  And, two black women in the Democratic Party are now hasbeens. 

Saturday, August 26, 2017

Drastic Measures

The issue of criminal justice remains Martin O'Malley's greatest Achilles heel when the 2020 election cycle begins.  O'Malley has coyly hinted that he will run for President then ("I just might," he's fond of saying), but if he does, his oversight of the Baltimore Police Department as that city's mayor will remain an issue for his foes - and he has many in Maryland - to use as a club on him.  Which is ironic, since that's what Baltimore policemen are accused of doing - using clubs.  Among other things.
O'Malley (above, in 2002, when he was mayor of Baltimore) resorted to zero-tolerance policing when he took over the worst city in America for violent crime and used drastic measures to make the once-prosperous industrial city safer.  His policies, though, encouraged an already existing culture of brutality waged against civilians by the police, and much of his approach was challenged - successfully - by the American Civil Liberties Union and the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People.  In January 2017 - ten years after he left office to become governor of Maryland - the U.S. Justice Department, in one of its last actions before Loretta Lynch handed the keys to Jeff Sessions, found numerous violations of the Constitution and of civil rights in investigating the Baltimore Police Department's patterns and practices that many people linked to O'Malley's policies.
The investigation, for the record, primarily looked at the Baltimore police's record in the decade after O'Malley left office, and one of his successors, former mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake, admitted that change and reform can be slow.  Cops normally violate constitutional rights in Baltimore despite rigorous training, and they're partial to calling blacks by all sorts of racial epithets, and not just that word.  They get brutal with black suspects, and they get furious at and physically brutal against some black residents for just existing.  This is in a city that is two-thirds black.  Officers don't know how to handle sensitive matters that could and do get violent, and they're under pressure to show results to satisfy the city's Comstat system, a police-data system O'Malley initiated and has lauded,  which uses analytics and numbers to achieve efficient results.  
Anthony Barksdale, a high-ranking black police official in Baltimore who headed a squad focusing on the most violent offenders, insisted that the Justice Department's investigation of some circumstances made race more important than it appeared.  Barksdale noted that the massive arrests, stops and crackdowns in targeted neighborhoods was based on not the racial makeup of these neighborhoods but on the violent crimes in them.  "What the [Justice Department] didn't do is overlay the crime map on those stop maps," he says.
Barksdale said there was also training on constitutional issues and admitted that there were violations based on the failure of commanders to reinforce it, but he was optimistic that continued training can lead to greater reform.
Such nuances don't matter in politics.  O'Malley has shown time after time that he is no bigot, especially in his record as governor of Maryland and his commitment to equality for all.  But his failure to get a handle on the criminal element in the Baltimore police as mayor - as opposed to the criminal element the police are supposed to protect people from - will remain a sore spot for him unless he deals with it.  After all, he has the weight of constitutional violation by his police force around his neck, and if he ran for President again he would have to do more than mend fences with black voters - he'd have to tear down the fence and start over from scratch.  Also, imagine an O'Malley still hobbled by his criminal-justice record going up against Donald Trump - blacks might just want to throw up their hands and stay home, crippling an already disabled Democratic Party.
As I publish this, Trump has pardoned former Maricopa County, Arizona sheriff Joe Arpaio for defying a court order against the illegal tactics he used to crack down on undocumented immigrants.  O'Malley has never done anything like that - he's a champion of immigrants' rights, incidentally - but given the Baltimore police's reputation for disregarding the law, a Democratic presidential primary opponent might want to draw a parallel between Baltimore and Maricopa County (which includes Phoenix) and make it look like Arpaio is O'Malley's brother in arms.  
If O'Malley is going to have a chance in 2020, he's going to have to acknowledge the Baltimore Police Department's mistakes - and his own. Like putting too much faith in Comstat.  "Comstat, or 'goal oriented community policing,' has saved thousands of American lives in cities all across our nation," he recently wrote in an online editorial.  "In some places, the improvement in policing continues as more and more lives are saved. New York and Los Angeles in particular have figured out how to improve public safety while, at the same time, improving public trust  -  the basis of all security for any free people."
Alas, OMalley wasn't the mayor of either of those cities.  He was the mayor of Baltimore, and while he may have inherited a city with a police department that makes the Los Angeles Police Department look like the Mayberry sheriff's office (and it was probably just as corrupt when Thomas D'Alesandro III - Nancy Pelosi's older brother - was mayor of Baltimore in the late sixties, during the last major  Baltimore riot before the Freddie Gray scandal), he didn't leave it in any better shape for the three black female mayors who succeeded him. Without intending to, he may have even left it in even worse shape to some extent.  Yes, Baltimore is a tough town to govern and make safe, and yes, all of these problems existed long before O'Malley was on the scene.  But none of Baltimore's other mayors ever ran for President, either.
The Justice Department's report came out long after O'Malley was forced to withdraw as a candidate for President, so this will just be one more weapon his enemies will use against him in 2020 if he choose to run for President then.  The only reason his record as mayor of Baltimore wasn't a big deal in 2016 was because he wasn't a big deal.  I can assure you, though, that had O'Malley emerged as Hillary Clinton's chief Democratic primary opponent, she would have used his criminal-justice record as Baltimore mayor to destroy him. 
O'Malley did what he did as mayor of Baltimore to fight crime because he believed that drastic measures were necessary.  This time he has to take drastic measures to fight to save his own viability as a presidential candidate.  I'm still for the guy, and I still want him to run for President again, but he has to do and say more than he's said or done so far about his criminal-justice policies.  And now.  And fast.
By the way, I'm not calling him Marty anymore.  He loathes the nickname.  Besides, that's what his worst enemies - not all of whom are in Maryland - call him.  

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

Justice Done?

Attorney General Eric Holder announced that he would seek the trial of 9/11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed and four others through the military tribunal system, at the Guantanamo Bay detention center - and not, as Holder wanted, in a civilian court on the American mainland.
America had a chance to demonstrate the beauty of its imperfect but superior judicial system by giving Mohammed a fair and impartial trial, in New York, through due process of law, and with confidence from Holder that the government could get a conviction with its evidence against Mohammed and his own guilty plea. But so many members of Congress from both parties - as well as many New Yorkers - were afraid of the need for extra security and the costs to provide it, as well as the inconvenience involved, that Holder was forced to retrench and retreat.
I don't understand what Americans are afraid of. Khalid Sheikh Mohammed would have stood an excellent chance of conviction after all of the liberties afforded to him as a defendant under the American legal system. Holder has what is easily an airtight case against him. New York City mayor Michael Bloomberg and his police commissioner, Ray Kelly, were for the plan to try Mohammed in New York before they were against it. So were several other politicians who later proved to be less than profiles in courage. If logistics in holding the trial in Lower Manhattan - which is a narrow tip of an island - were a problem - why not hold the trial in upstate New York, in Newburgh, for example, as had been suggested? And is Mohammed really as much of a threat to people's security while in custody as he was as a free man plotting 9/11?
Holder made it clear that he was moving the trial to a military tribunal - the differences between which and a civilian trial are still unclear to many people - under protest, citing Congress's refusal to provide funds to close Guantanamo Bay facility and move its prisoners to a detention center in rural Illinois, as well as its refusal to provide money to transfer Mohammed to New York for trial. He apparently hoped to assuage civil libertarians with this comment, adding that Congress demonstrated its lack of familiarity with this case. Hmm, it seems the Holder himself didn't make the argument for his civilian trial proposal strongly enough over the past few months, nor did the White House make it forcefully either.
Politics ultimately doomed the hope of trying Mohammed in a public arena and allowing the judicial system to work fairly before the eyes of the world. Politics led to the secretive tribunal now being planned. It's a big shame.