Showing posts with label Corporation for Public Broadcasting. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Corporation for Public Broadcasting. Show all posts

Sunday, August 3, 2025

RIP CPB

It happened.  What Richard Nixon, Donald Wildmon, Newt Gingrich, and Mick Mulvaney all failed to do in the past, Donald J. Trump did in one fell swoop.  He forced the Corporation for Public Broadcasting to go out of business.

The Corporation for Public Broadcasting, the somewhat makeshift entity that doles out federal funds, suddenly found itself with no funds to dole out after Trump and his henchmen succeeded in zeroing out funding for public broadcasting in retaliation for a perceived liberal bias in PBS's and NPR's news reporting.  That bias must have been a surprise to Margaret Hoover, the great-granddaughter of the thirty-first U.S. President, who currently hosts the right-leaning PBS talk show "The Firing Line," as well as to longtime viewers of PBS's "NewsHour" broadcast, which gets "funding" from such major corporations as BNSF Railway.  (After too much fluff pretending to be news, like stories on hip-hop culture and those stupid "Brief but Spectacular" essays which are neither, I stopped watching the NewsHour altogether, as you already know.) And National Public Radio tends to broadcast talk shows - many of them boring - that have nothing to do with politics of any sort.  But the "liberal bias" myth, unlike the Corporation for Public Broadcasting, endures. 

As far as I'm concerned, good riddance.  I'm glad that the Corporation for Public Broadcasting is biting the dust, mainly because public broadcasting has become so unbelievably pretentious, from the miniseries set in the Regency and Victorian eras of nineteenth-century England on PBS to the Sunday-morning folk-music shows on NPR-affiliated stations that always feature Tom Chapin songs, cuts from David Crosby's solo albums, and Joni Mitchell wannabes singing about saving the whales or building more affordable housing - in other words, public broadcasting caters to the tastes of white bourgeois liberals, the same demographic that even bothers to vote on public broadcasting to begin with.  But given PBS's history with airing Lawrence Welk reruns,  John Tesh concerts, and those tiresome, tedious nostalgia concerts - public-broadcasting programming has more in common with Richard Nader than with Ralph Nader - it's a wonder how white bourgeois liberals could continue to believe that public broadcasting in These States was ever anything like the BBC.  The loss of the Corporation for Public Broadcasting pulls that mask off, but the mask was a bandit eye mask that allowed you to still determine the wearer's features.  People who thought public broadcasting was a truly independent alternative to mainstream commercial broadcasting should have seen right through that disguise all along.  Now they have no alternative but to face the truth.

We'll still have public broadcasting in some form, but now more than ever, local stations will have to rely on local funding.  Get ready for longer pledge-drive interruptions during "special" PBS programming like your local station airing the memorial concert for George Harrison for the 674,258th time.  But it's time to admit that public broadcasting in America - made possible by a grant from an oil company - is not, never was, and never will be anything like the BBC.  My observation is not a popular one, and I lost a friend who raises (raised?) money for a local public-television station by pointing this out to her, but let's face it . . .

How come National Public Radio never aired live performances of popular-music acts now considered "classic rock" and allowed them to be put out as records years after (the albums above don't really exist), as BBC Radio has done? 

Yes, it's too bad we don't have anything like the BBC in These States, but as a New York magazine writer once said twenty years ago, deal with it - there are more important battles against reactionaries to fight.

The Corporation for Public Broadcasting disbands at the end of September. 

Monday, July 31, 2023

CPB Versus BBC

As I noted in my previous post, the far right wants to dismantle public broadcasting as we know it.  Granted, public broadcasting as we know it is mediocre at best. Public television (PBS) may be ad hoc and random, but its programming is still in many cases superior to programs offered on network television or basic cable, while it is on par with programming on premium cable or streaming services many of us cannot afford. And anyone can watch public television.  Public radio? National Public Radio (NPR) clearly lacks nationwide music programming, focusing mostly on talk shows on topics ranging from politics to movies, but local public music stations affiliated with NPR do a decent job playing artists that tend to sell one record for every ten thousand records Taylor Swift sells. 
None of that means anything to conservatives like Mike Gonzalez, who in Project 2025's manifesto devotes a whole subchapter to the Corporation for Public Broadcasting (CPB) and complains about the 65 percent of viewers and listeners who identify as liberal and complains about the programming as being biased toward liberal values (forget Margaret Hoover resurrecting "Firing Line," the old PBS talk show begun by the late WIlliam F. Buckley, Jr.). Gonzalez sneers at the CPB receiving government subsidies to provide non-commercial educational funding when he finds even "Sesame Street" as a form of liberal indoctrination (because Sesame Street is in a racially mixed urban neighborhood where half of everyone speaks Spanish). 
The big complaint from liberals, of course, is that PBS and NPR receives corporate funding, which, conservatives want the CPB to rely on exclusively, and is thus discouraged from broadcasting anything that might offend their corporate "underwriters."  Ironically, Gonzalez points this out in his concluding paragraph. "NPR and PBS stations are in reality no longer noncommercial, as they run ads in everything but name for their sponsors," he writes. "They are also non-educational. The next President should instruct the FCC to exclude the stations affiliated with PBS and NPR from the [non-commercial educational] denomination and the privileges that come with it." 
Public broadcasting non-educational? Let me rebut that in the only way I know how. First, watch a history documentary on PBS. It doesn't matter which one, just watch it. Then try to find a comparable documentary on the History Channel, which for the most part stopped being about history years ago. Conservatives have long insisted that any public funding of broadcasting is a mistake, with Antonin Scalia, as a Nixon administration lawyer in 1971, warning of "a long-range problem of significant social consequences - that is, the development of a government-funded broadcast system similar to the BBC." 
The British Broadcasting Corporation is not, as far as I am aware of, in the business of spreading socialist propaganda, but it does provide original scripted comedies and dramas and a world-class news-gathering service, as well as five national music radio stations - including BBC Radio 1, which, like its predecessor, the BBC Light Programme, has a storied legacy of live performances from bands now considered "classic rock." The Corporation for Public Broadcasting has none of those things, thanks to a funding system that barely qualifies as a system - a mix of corporate funding, individual donations, and annual federal subsidies, meaning that PBS has to import original scripted programming from television networks from other countries (like the BBC) and settle for a second-rate TV newscast that gets half of its foreign news reports from Britain's Independent Television News.  That only goes to show you how a dedicated funding mechanism can make a difference for public broadcasting; the BBC is funded by an annual £159 ($216.60) license fee paid by all British households that make use of its services . . . which is practically everyone in the United Kingdom.  You get what you pay for.
If this all sounds familiar, it's because I've been saying it time and time again on this blog.
If Project 2025 goes forward as planned under a Republican President as far as public broadcasting is concerned, we can expect to see funding for public broadcasting zeroed out and completely dependent on wealthy donors, which will no doubt limit even further the CPB's ability to provide the sort of programming it does now. PBS will be like the basic-cable channels that used to air educational programs but stopped doing so when it turned out to be unprofitable. (TLC, which used to stand for The Learning Channel, now shows reality programming and its name is just a bunch of meaningless initials.)  PBS and NPR stations in small media markets will go off the air for lack of funding with no alternative public-affairs programming, just as sure as, as noted in my previous post, the Republicans will restrict commercial media providing alternatives to news and opinion with a conservative bent.  Several NPR-affiliated music stations may go off the air, denying people in small media markets an alternative to a commercial music station playing Justin Bieber. 
But it's not like we won't have government-sanctioned media in place of public broadcasting.  We will.  In fact, a leading Republican already has one set up.
His name is Rupert Murdoch.

Sunday, March 13, 2022

Public Broadcasting: Recipe For Disaster

  • Establish a non-profit, publicly funded broadcasting system in America, like people in European countries have.
  • Do not fund it, however, with a dedicated tax. Instead, encourage the American people to fund it voluntarily, with a small annual congressional appropriation.
  • Have your new corporation, for Corporation for Public Broadcasting, set up a television system and a radio system. Give each a different leadership and a different name – call the TV system Public Broadcasting Service and the radio system National Public Radio – so as to make it obvious that it’s not a uniform system with any since of cohesion or structure.
  • Create as many TV and radio stations as possible in a single metropolitan area to allow room for both local and national programming, but leave each of the stations to figure things out for themselves so no one has any real idea of what’s going on.
  • Allow each of the different TV stations in one area to broadcast the same national programming at different times, so as to muddle the mission statement for local programming and kill any chances of looking like a coherent network.
  • Encourage music on local radio stations affiliated with your network but devote practically all national radio programming to talk and public affairs. If you have two local sister stations on AM and FM, muddy things up further by having different programming in only a few time slots. Avoid all appearances of a single national network, even though the BBC has seven national radio stations.
  • Add corporate sponsorship when a Republican administration has the federal stipend reduced. Call your sponsors "underwriters" and your sponsorships "grants."
  • Air a talk show hosted by the founder of National Review on your television system, relaunch it after his death with the great-granddaughter of a Republican President as host, and let charges of liberal bias go unchallenged.
  • Air middlebrow twaddle like John Tesh concerts and Michael Flatley dance specials on your TV stations during pledge drives, rather than the opera and ballet you’re supposed to be showing. If you air any thing associated with Andrew Lloyd Webber, keep a straight face when you talk about the importance of bringing high art to television.
  • Survive on so little money, your TV network can produce only documentaries and very little dramatic programming. Import dramatic programming from England and Australia. Import foreign news reports for your news department from ITV in England while you’re at it.
  • When things get really desperate, start importing dramas from non-English-speaking countries for good measure.
  • Throw in reruns of "The Lawrence Welk Show" for good measure.  When the audience for that dies out, air various-artist oldies concerts.
If you follow this recipe, you will be a joke, and right-wing spoiled rich kids looking for cheap publicity will come after you.