Showing posts with label Albert Speer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Albert Speer. Show all posts

Wednesday, February 4, 2026

Closed For Repairs?

Donald Trump has announced that the Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts will be closed for "renovations" beginning July 4, 2026.
He promises that it will be better and more beautiful than before.  And Broadway star Patti LuPone, among others, are weighing in on Trump's as-yet unseen plans, with LuPone, below, worried that Trump might tear the building down, and -- 
Wait, what?
Patti LuPone actually wants to see the current Kennedy Center preserved?  Ha ha, that's the funniest thing I've heard all week!
As I have noted before on this blog, the Kennedy Center is considered one of the monumentally horrid examples of the the grandiose and pretentious examples of  post-war American architecture, known for its pompous corridors and its oversized theaters, while the performing "arts" events staged there are the sort of middlebrow entertainment that would never be allowed in halls like the Paris Opera House or la Scala.  And there's that really, really ugly - and huge - bust of John F. Kennedy that looks like someone threw mud on a wire model of a human skull until the image looked like JFK, at least just a bit.  The surest sign that no architectural standards exist in These States in these days is that people actually find no objection with the design of the current performing arts complex, a building that has sat like a giant warehouse with eaves defiling the eastern bank of the Potomac.
I rarely reproduce entire articles on this blog, but when I do, it's to make a serious point.  And so I do so now, reprinting architecture critic Ada Louise Huxtable's bashing of the Kennedy Center's architecture in a review published in the New York Times on Tuesday, September 7, 1971, a day before it officially opened to the public.  It is quite trenchant.
*
This capital city specializes in ballooning monuments and endless corridors. It uses marble like cotton wool. It is the home of government of, for and by the people, and of taste for the people - the big, the bland and the banal. The John F. Kennedy Center for the Performing Arts, opening officially Wednesday, does not break the rule. The style of the Kennedy Center is Washington superscale, but just a little bit bigger. Albert Speer would have approved.
It has apotheosized the corridor in the 600‐foot‐long, 60‐foot‐high grand foyer (the length of three New York City blockfronts), one of the biggest rooms in the world, into which the Hall of Mirrors at Versailles could he cozily nested. It would be a super-tunnel without its saving Belgian gift of mirrors.
The corridor is “dressed up,” in the words of the architect, Edward Durell Stone, by 18 of the world's biggest crystal chandeliers, with planters and furniture still to come. There is enough red carpet for a total environment.
There are two other flag-hung, polished marble-walled, red‐carpeted, 250‐foot long and 60‐foot high corridors called the Hall of States and the Hall of Nations. They are disquietingly reminiscent of the overscaled vacuity of Soviet palaces of culture. They would be great for drag racing.
The two halls separate the three theaters that are the structure's raison d'être: the Opera House, the Concert Hall and the Eisenhower Theater. The grand foyer is the entrance to them all.
The building itself is a super-bunker, 100 feet high, 630 feet long and 300 feet wide, on the Potomac. One more like this and the city will sink.
Because it is a national landmark, there is only one way to judge the Kennedy Center - against the established standard of progressive and innovative, excellence in architectural design that this country is known and admired for internationally.
Unfortunately, the Kennedy center not only does not achieve this standard of innovative excellence; it also did not seek it. The architect opted for something ambiguously called "timelessness" and produced meaninglessness. It is to the Washington manner born. Too bad; since there is so much of it.
The center sets still another record—for architectural default. What it has in size, it lacks in distinction. Its character is aggrandized posh. It is an embarrassment to have it stand as a symbol of American artistic, achievement before the nation and the world.
The interiors aim for conventional, comfortable, gargantuan grand luxe. This is gemütlich Speer.
The Opera House, a 2,200‐seat hall with superior sightliness and equipment, looks like one of those passe, red-padded drugstore candy‐valentines.
Its dark red fabric walls are buttoned down with rows of gold knobs and its Austrian crystal lights suggest nothing so much as department store Christmas displays. To this observer, it is singularly depressing.
The 2,375‐seat Concert Hall, its acoustic wood walls painted white, has red seats and carpet and is buttoned down with Norwegian crystal fixtures. This at least is cheerful and suggests 1920s-modern.
Restaurants on the top terrace floor are in expense‐account French by way of Austria, and nearly Scandinavia. They are red.
There are two ways of defending the center's design. One, already popular, is to say that it doesn't really matter and that the only things that count are those badly needed performance halls and how they work.
But nothing justifies wrapping those halls in nearly $70 million of tasteful corn and 17,000 tons of steel -all a conscious design decision - and ignoring it. If you could ignore it, which is hard.
To say that everything else about a landmark structure of this stupefying size is irrelevant is nonsense. The emperor, unfortunately, is wearing clothes. And the world is looking.
The second defense is simply to accept the fact that the center probably represents the norm of American, taste. But it is a fallacy to equate the great middle common denomination of popular taste with the country's actual and potential level of creative achievement.
From this point of view, however, it is almost an interesting building. If Mr. Stone has been aiming for an architecture that all America can love, he has found it This is architectural populism. He has produced a conventional crowd pleaser. It is a genuine people's palace.
People have been pouring in, before the opening, through every available crack, in T‐shirts and sneakers, hot pants and Bermuda shorts, barefoot and bare-bellied, backpacking babies, tracking across the red carpet and under the chandeliers. The pre‐opening charge of elitism because of all that lush decor was rubbish. They are obviously loving it and perfectly at home.
Because it so lacks the true elegance of imagination, it does not put them off at all. They are awed by the scale and admiring of the decoration, which is a safe, familiar blend of theatrical glamour and showroom Castro Convertible.
Stringent economies have made saving simplicities, but the popular style is loud and clear.
For the more architecturally sophisticated, it is hard to admire a failure of vision and art. And it did not have to be it is not easy to commission creative courage in Washington, but it can be done, as proven by the current plans for the National Gallery extension.
It is particularly hard to know that the one creative design for a new kind of experimental theater remains an unfinished shell within the building, lacking funds.
The center was probably wrong from the start. It was conceived as a giant economy three‐in‐one package. If it hasn't cost more than three separate buildings, it certainly hasn't cost less, and it has had formidable construction problems as a result of the "simple" concept.
The three houses have had to be separated and insulated from each other for vibration and sound inside and jets outside, and from other floors and functions.
Suspension and soundproofing have been achieved through incredibly complex and expensive concrete and steelwork that belies the apparent logic of the plan. Structurally, the achievement is considerable, and economically, it is almost a bargain.
The giant steel trusses hidden behind the scenes are far more impressive, than the truly awful, gold‐epoxy‐paint-steel columns that run visibly through the building, which add decorative aluminum fins along the facades.
Environmentally, the center has been severely criticized for its setting and isolation from city life. But many Washingtonians like the idea of driving to a “safe” bastion of culture. Again, it's what people really want.
As completed, the center's plusses include its public amenities—its entrance plaza, riverfront promenade, eating facilities and outdoor terraces with views. And credit as well as sympathy must go to the dedicated and hardworking sponsors who have actually brought three major performance halls to Washington.
May all the performing arts flourish. Because the building is a national tragedy. It is a cross between a concrete candy box and a marble sarcophagus in which the art of architecture lies buried.
*
In other words, it's the perfect populist palace for a performing "arts" complex where honors go to female rappers who got their start in show business making percussive noises with their mouths on the streets of Newark and clown-faced electric-guitar players whose band name is an accidental acronym for their "musical" style - "Keep it simple, stupid." 
Note that Albert Speer - still alive in 1971 - got mentioned twice in Huxtable's appraisal, and yes, he probably did approve.
So, yes, I say, tear it down, especially in light of the fact that a theater actress who made a name for herself playing a fascist concubine in a musical written by Western civilization's worst composer is the last person who should judge the architectural quality of the Kennedy Center.  But at least, Ms. LuPone only played a fascist concubine, which is certainly a whole lot better than being one, one now celebrated in a documentary no one wants to see.
But there's the thing.  As horrid as the Kennedy Center looks from the outside (to be fair, the interior has been renovated in the past, though I hardly see how it could be better now than when it first opened), it's probably better to wait to tear it down and replace it with something that Ada Louise Huxtable would have liked until Trump is out of office, because if he does tear it down, the new performing arts complex will probably look something like this.
In fact, it could end up being worse than this.  How?  I don't let myself think about it.    

Wednesday, August 13, 2025

An American Germania

Trump wants to put his own stamp on Washington, D.C.   And nothing allows him to put his imprimatur on the nation's capital more than having the National Guard and other units of the military take over policing in the District of Columbia.

The ostensible reason for sending National Guard troops to the District is to rein in out-of-control crime in the city after one of Elon Musk's former Department of Government Efficiency henchmen got assaulted in a car-theft attempt.  But the real reason that Trump is laying down the law - martial law - in D.C. is because he's a white man who wants to dominate a black-majority city whose mayor is a black woman.  It couldn't really be because of rampant crime - crime has dropped considerably in Washington for years now.  If Trump wanted to do something about out-of-control crime, he'd have sent troops to New Orleans or Atlanta - cities in Republican states.  The cities Trump plans to take his military-dictatorship road show to  - he has mentioned Chicago, Detroit and Philadelphia - are cities with large black populations in states with Democratic governors.  And New York City, his former hometown, could be next, assuming Zohran Mamdani is elected mayor in November.  And if Mikie Sherill is elected governor of New Jersey - an electoral outcome I seriously doubt at this point - Newark, which is overwhelmingly black and Hispanic and has a mayor named Ras Baraka (instead of Ralph Jones, which would likely be his name had his poet-playwright father not changed the family name from Jones to Baraka), would certainly be added to the list.  (And maybe overwhelmingly black East Orange next door, as long as the troops are in the neighborhood.)  All of this is just fine with the Republicans, who are ready with rejoinders on the need to fight crime - a reality for many even in America's safest cities - when the Democrats inevitably object to Trump's actions.  

None of that accounts for why Trump chose Washington to make an example of before any other places, having already made an example out of Los Angeles.  Trump, quite bluntly, wants to remake Washington in his image.  Why else would he be planning to build a ballroom for the White House?  Why else would he take over the Kennedy Center?  His plans to turn Washington into a Mar-a-Lago-style utopia is redolent of Adolf Hitler's plan to turn Berlin into Germania, a grand city Hitler had hoped would dwarf ancient Rome and modern Rome as well.  He had his architect Albert Speer draw up plans for a domed assembly hall so huge it would end up having its own weather inside.  When all is said and done, Speer may end up having accomplished less in Berlin than what Trump's sycophantic architects and construction firms pull off in Washington.  Trump is certainly drawn to grandiose projects much like Hitler was, and he shares an artistic sensibility with Hitler toward using size and ornament to send a message as to who is the leader and that the leader shall not be opposed or questioned.  Hitler had been a watercolor artist and knew how art and architecture could be used to project an image of strength.  Likewise, Trump has been a real estate developer with a taste for opulence and knows how to project power and wealth in his buildings.  The only difference between Hitler and Trump is that Trump may actually have more money than Hitler did.

It is therefore in Washington where Trump is planning to create a citadel of power and domination, where every aspect of life conforms to the whims of the leader.  If the White House becomes another Chancellery, what can we expect of the Capitol?  The Smithsonian Institution is already having its mission statement rewritten to emphasize a feel-good historical narrative of the nation as viewed by white patriarchs wearing rose-colored glasses rather than the multiethnic story of struggle and adversity that American history really is.  By turning the Smithsonian into a repository of the sort of history represented in children's biographies of famous Americans - biographies that leave out all of the flaws and faults of our historical figures - Trump is infantilizing the country's story.

Trump wants to enforce this with his occupying military force in the nation's capital.  It's his show, and he's directing it like the pseudo-documentarian reality TV series he once hosted.  But what happens when the fantasy is over?

Let's just say Hitler learned the answer to that question the hard way when the Red Army entered Berlin in 1945.

Tuesday, August 5, 2025

Tear Down This House!

This one.

Okay, now that I have your attention . . . let me set things up here.  Donald Trump is planning to make a major change to the White House, something that would never have appeared on Kamala Harris' to-do list or anyone else's . . . he's going to have a new White House ballroom built, with construction set to start later this fall.

He plans to have it done before January 2029, when he's scheduled to leave office.

It would replace much of the East Wing, as seen below.

Wonder why the rendering shows it in the wintertime?
As out of scale as it looks on the outside, the planned ballroom is just plain gaudy inside, with the inevitable excessive use of gold leaf.
More opulent than elegant, this planned expansion of the White House suggests comparisons to Mar-a-Lago for many, but for me I can't help but think of Adolf Hitler's Chancellery in Berlin, with its emphasis on size and ornament, which was designed by the Führer's sycophantic court architect, Albert Speer.
The Kennedy Center has also been compared to Hitler's palace, but at least the Kennedy Center isn't anyone's actual residence.  Someone's residency, yes; someone's residence, no.  The White House is the home of the President of the United States, who, more than a famous Hollywood actor, a renowned captain of industry, or an overexposed helium-voiced pop singer from Detroit, is America to the world.  And the White House is supposed to represent our values, not one President's.  This is different from President Truman having a bowling alley installed or President Ford adding an outdoor swimming pool.  This cheapens and degrades the executive mansion!
But, at this point, I am a fully committed secessionist, and I hope to see Trump become the last President of the United States before the country goes the way of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics.  Because Washington, D.C. was culled from 64 square miles of the Maryland side of the Potomac River (Virginia added 36 square miles so that the District of Columbia would be ten miles square -100 square miles - but requested it returned in 1846; ironically, those 36 square miles became the city of Arlington, which is the home of the Pentagon and Arlington National Cemetery), I had imagined that Washington would become the capital of what ever post-American republic Maryland ended up being in, or maybe become the new capital of Canada if the northeastern states became Canadian provinces, another option worth considering, but now I know that Washington can't be the capital of any post-Union country.  Trump has already sullied it with changes to the White House already, such having just had the Rose Garden lawn being paved with granite (Hitler liked granite) and having already gotten rid of the trees in his first presidential term (Hitler got rid of the trees along Berlin's grand boulevard, the Unter den Linden, which got its name from those very trees, to have more state parades).  He's already wrecked havoc on the Kennedy Center.  What does he have planned for the Capital and the Supreme Court?  And is the Martin Luther King, Jr. Memorial in jeopardy of being dismantled?
Therefore, I propose the following ideas once Washington, D.C, is no longer the capital of anything.  
First, return it to Maryland.  To avoid the prospect of Maryland having to rescue another failing city when it's already saddled with Baltimore, divide Washington into smaller towns and either add them to existing Maryland counties or make the old District of Columbia a new county - name it Douglass County, after famous Marylander Frederick Douglass.
Second, repurpose the government buildings for apartments or office space.  As for the Capitol, turn it into an art museum, as the Louvre palace in Paris became an art museum.  The Supreme Court can become a new performing arts complex to replace the spectacularly ugly Kennedy Center.   Wall up the Lincoln and Jefferson Memorials and, once the interiors are gutted and the statues are placed elsewhere, preferably in their states of origin, turn them into four-star restaurants.  Like Maison Robert in Boston occupying the former city hall.
And the White House?  Tear it down, just as the Chancellery in Berlin was.  Expand the green space south from Lafayette Square.  Get rid of any trace of Donald Trump having ever been there.  Replace the site of the Oval Office with a monument dedicated to all of the immigrants who were rounded up in the second Trump term and never heard from again.  
(As for what to do with the Washington Monument . . . yeah, I have no idea.)
This wouldn't be the first time a city built to be a national capital would cease being one.  Bear in mind that the Russian czar Peter the Great built St. Petersburg on the Baltic Sea to be a showpiece capital for the Russian Empire and replace Moscow as the seat of government.  St. Petersburg is certainly a lovely city, but when the Bolsheviks took over Russia, Lenin decided that the city was too close to Russia's western border and moved the Russian capital back to Moscow, which would become both the capital of the U.S.S.R. and the Russian Soviet Federated Socialist Republic.  (And during the Soviet era, St. Petersburg was named Leningrad.)   St. Petersburg, however, is still a repository for Russian culture. Washington is only a seat of government.  It has no reason to exist without a country to be a seat of government for.
Just as the country it is the capital of has no reason to exist anymore.